Tarawa, the most easily accessible atoll in Kiribati, is a popular destination for journalists and activists interested in observing and communicating the impacts of sea-level rise on a low-lying nation... common images of flooded homes and waves crashing across the causeways—collected during an anomalous event on islets susceptible to flooding due in part to local modifications to the environment—can provide the false impression that Tarawa is subject to constant flooding because of sea-level rise.
Kiribati's Atoll (photo by author)
Tarawa and the rest of Kiribati are certainly under serious long-term threat from sea-level rise. The concern expressed in last year's paper is the effects of shoddy research and loose talk by journalists and climate activists, inside and outside of Kiribati, about specific events:
Such unverified attribution can inflame or invite skepticism of the scientific evidence for a human-caused increase in the global sea-level.
I now bring you Exhibit A: "Kiribati: A Nation Going Under" by Bernard in the Kiwi publication the Global Mail, published a couple weeks ago when I was in the field.
Running out of options, and water, a nation’s leader enters an end game against climate change. The President of Kiribati urges an orderly evacuation — “migration with dignity”.
Rare among international coverage of Kiribati, the article goes into accurate detail about the many local issues beyond climate change and is tough on President Tong, who is usually lionized by the international press. Yet the article still butchers the evidence for impacts of sea-level rise, falling for the tempting bait I describe in the Donner (2012): flooding and erosion caused by climate variability and shoreline modification. It is a shame because otherwise, the article is one of few I've seen to capture the complex politics of responding to threats of climate change in this remote, developing nation.


No comments:
Post a Comment